QAmcp

Copied. Paste it into Claude Code, Cursor or Codex:Fetch and follow the instructions at https://qamcp.dev/setup.md to test my MCP server.

Your AI finds your server in your project, tests it with QAmcp, explains what's wrong in plain words, fixes it with your OK, and tests again. Read the instructions

SoonYour score can change any day. QAmcp Monitor tests your server every hour and emails you when it breaks.See what Monitor does →

Directory / Verdict

Verdict

Q: Is Verdict MCP server safe?

QAmcp's test on 30 Oct 2026: No hidden instructions were found in its tool descriptions. Its error messages showed no secrets or internal details. All 6 of its tools are labeled read-only. Overall it scored 70/100 on 30 Oct 2026. A test can only see what the server shows from outside, not what it does with your data behind the scenes. Connect servers from makers you trust.

by verdict.allthepossibles.com · https://verdict.allthepossibles.com/mcp

Design review as MCP tools: critique, states, journeys, UI copy, PRD assumptions. BYOK or hosted.

6 tools✓ all read-only✓ no account neededPricing: not listed

Visit website

70 /100

FAIL

11 of 11 checks · 30 Oct 2026

Is Verdict MCP server safe?

No hidden instructions were found in its tool descriptions.
Its error messages showed no secrets or internal details.
All 6 of its tools are labeled read-only.
Overall it scored 70/100 on 30 Oct 2026.

A test can only see what the server shows from outside, not what it does with your data behind the scenes. Connect servers from makers you trust.

What it can do

6 tools, in the server's own words.

critique_experienceread-only

Adversarial critique of a design, given as a description or a screenshot URL, with an optional PRD.

generate_state_matrixread-only

Generates the state space for a feature, form or screen across data, loading, permission, network, account, content, time, concurrency, outside dependencies, m…

map_journeyread-only

Breaks a user objective into the stages of a real journey and flags entry points and exit paths that have no designed arrival or recovery.

audit_copyread-only

Per-string critique of interface copy: buttons, errors, empty states, confirmations, notifications.

find_assumptionsread-only

Reads a PRD or design brief and extracts the unverified assumptions inside it, ranked by risk, each turned into a research question that could change a decisio…

check_terminologyread-only

Finds concepts that carry different names across surfaces (UI strings, docs, API reference, support macros) and flags drift.

Test results

Safe mode: only tools labeled read-only were run. How the test works

✕
Tools work with good inputs
1 failed
- ✕map_journey: No answer within the time limit
- –critique_experience: Not run: labeled read-only, but its description says "irreversible", which usually means it changes something. Skipped to be safe: if it only reads, a clearer description helps AI apps too, or test again with --owner
- and 4 more
fail
!
Ready for the newest MCP version
1 warning
- !Uses an older MCP version (2025-06-18). It works today, but it isn't on the July 2026 version (2026-07-28) yet.
note
!
Every tool is described
3 warnings
- !map_journey: Inputs with no description: user_maturity
- !audit_copy: Inputs with no description: strings
- !check_terminology: Inputs with no description: sources
note
!
Fast enough
1 warning
- !generate_state_matrix: Slowest tool: generate_state_matrix (6.3 s): users will notice the wait
- and 3 more
note
!
Follows MCP best practices (not scored yet)
1 tip (not scored)
- !1 tool answers with structured data but doesn't declare its shape (outputSchema): generate_state_matrix. If those answers change shape, nothing can catch it; with a schema, every answer is checked.
note
✓
ConnectsConnected in 197 ms
pass
✓
Lists its toolsFound 6 tools
pass
✓
Tools are labeled safe or dangerousEvery tool has a safety label
pass
✓
No hidden instructionsNo hidden instructions found in tool descriptions
pass
✓
Bad inputs give a clean error
All good
- ✓generate_state_matrix: Refused missing required input "feature_description" with a clear error
- ✓generate_state_matrix: Refused wrong type for "feature_description" with a clear error
- ✓map_journey: Refused missing required input "objective" with a clear error
- ✓map_journey: Refused wrong type for "objective" with a clear error
- ✓audit_copy: Refused missing required input "strings" with a clear error
- ✓audit_copy: Refused wrong type for "strings" with a clear error
- ✓find_assumptions: Refused missing required input "prd_text" with a clear error
- ✓find_assumptions: Refused wrong type for "prd_text" with a clear error
- and 2 more
pass
✓
No secrets leakedChecked 14 error messages: no secrets or internal details
pass
–
Tools work togetherNo tool's answer could be fed into another tool, so there were no chains to test (not counted either way)
not tested

Test it yourself

Free and open source. Same checks, same score.

npx qamcp-cli https://verdict.allthepossibles.com/mcp

Show this score on GitHub

Free for every server in the directory. Paste this into your README: the badge shows the score from our latest test.

[![QAmcp score](https://qamcp.dev/s/com-allthepossibles-verdict.svg)](https://qamcp.dev/s/com-allthepossibles-verdict.html)

Score over time

30 Oct 202670

One test so far. New tests will show here.

Reviews

Coming soon: reviews from people who use Verdict, signed in with GitHub, one per person. Reviews never change the score.

Is this your server? Get an alert the moment it breaks.

QAmcp Monitor (coming soon) tests it every hour and emails you when it goes down, the score drops, a tool changes or a secret leaks. You'll also be able to claim this page and get a verified owner mark. Founding price: $19/month for life for the first 50 teams.

Have a concern, or want it removed? Ask us and we'll take it off the list. How the directory works